Best Thanksgiving Pies in Toronto (2025)
Thanksgiving isn’t complete without pie. Whether you’re team pumpkin, classic apple, or craving something rich and nutty, Toronto has a strong lineup of bakeries ready to deliver. From old-school favourites to vegan sweet spots, here’s where to find pies worth sharing this holiday season.
10 Must-Try Thanksgiving Pies in Toronto Right Now
Wanda’s Pie in the Sky
This Kensington Market bakery has built a loyal following thanks to its hearty, homemade-style pies. Reddit users swear by their pumpkin, blueberry, and sour cherry options—especially during fall.
- Location: 287 Augusta Ave
- Best For: Pumpkin, wild blueberry, sour cherry
- Ordering: Preorders need 2 business days’ notice. Pickup and limited downtown delivery available
- Website: wandaspieinthesky.com
Sharman’s Proper Pies
Known more for savoury pies, this east-end spot also puts out solid dessert options. Their 9” pies or personal 5” versions are great for low-key gatherings.
- Location: 1972 Danforth Ave
- Best For: Apple, pumpkin, berry (rotating specials)
- Ordering: Bake-at-home or ready-made; in-store or delivery
- Website: sharmansproper.ca
Bobbette & Belle
This chic bakery rolls out seasonal pies each Thanksgiving—like classic pumpkin and apple crumble. Expect a polished, Instagram-ready finish.
- Locations: Queen St. East, Yonge St.
- Known For: Elegant presentation, gluten-free pies
- Ordering: Online preorders, limited bakery pickup
The Pie Commission
More than just dessert—this shop sells both sweet and savoury pies in frozen and ready-to-eat formats. Great for busy folks who still want something quality.
- Location: Etobicoke + select retailers
- Options: Apple crumble, raspberry vanilla, meat pies
- Ordering: In-store, frozen delivery options
Sweetie Pie
A neighbourhood favourite with multiple locations, Sweetie Pie is known for its indulgent bourbon pecan and deep-dish pumpkin pies.
- Locations: Harbord, Scarborough, Distillery
- Top Picks: Bourbon pecan, pumpkin, Dutch apple
- Ordering: Call-in for pickup or local delivery
Pies by Squires
A fun British-inspired pie shop operating inside The Man of Kent. They do savoury and dessert pies with flaky crusts and traditional fillings.
- Location: Ossington (inside pub)
- Style: Rustic crust, hearty fillings
- Ordering: Call ahead for seasonal menus
Bunner’s Bakeshop
Fully vegan and gluten-free, Bunner’s pies are a hit with those who have dietary needs but still want real flavour.- Locations: Kensington Market, Dundas West
- Popular Picks: Pumpkin pie, sweet potato, apple crumble
- Ordering: Holiday preorders recommended
Hot Oven Bakery
One of Toronto’s most reliable spots for traditional pies. They tend to go heavy on fruit fillings—perfect if you’re into apple or cherry.
- Locations: Bloor West, Kingsway, Roncesvalles
- Top Picks: Apple pie, cherry, mincemeat
- Ordering: Walk-ins or phone-in holiday orders
Bloom Baking Co.
A newer name popping up on social feeds. They focus on small-batch tarts and pies with a creative twist—like cranberry pear or maple cream.
- Pop-up Base: Often listed at local markets
- Style: Petite pies, strong visual appeal
- Ordering: Instagram DM or seasonal markets
Tartistry
This Etobicoke bakery leans into both sweet and savoury options. Their Thanksgiving lineup usually includes apple caramel, butter tarts, and more.
- Location: 1252 The Queensway
- Famous For: Apple caramel tart, pumpkin butter tarts
- Ordering: Online menu updates in October
More….
