Best Bang For Your Buck Pizzas in Downtown Toronto
In a city where skyline views are as common as breakups over brunch, finding something that makes you feel whole—really whole—should be as easy as grabbing a slice of pizza. But as we wander the streets of Downtown Toronto with our hearts set on cheese and a reasonable price tag, we can’t help but wonder: Is it possible to find a pizza that satisfies both your taste buds and your bank account?
Toronto’s food scene is as vibrant and eclectic as a Queen West vintage shop. Every street corner offers a different vibe, a new possibility, and a temptation to splurge on something that might not live up to the hype. But fear not—we’ve done the legwork for you and found the best bang-for-your-buck pizzas in Downtown Toronto that’ll leave you feeling both full and fiscally responsible.
Fresca Pizza — The Late-Night Love
Location: 302 College Street
Fresca Pizza is like that friend who’s always there when you need them most—usually at 2 a.m. when the night’s winding down and you’re craving something deliciously uncomplicated. Their slices start at just $5, making it one of the most wallet-friendly options in the city. The secret? Consistently good, cheesy slices that don’t pretend to be anything other than what they are: pure, carb-filled joy. With an unassuming storefront and a constant flow of customers, Fresca is proof that sometimes, the best things really do come in the simplest boxes.
- Instagram: frescapizzatoronto
Cibo Wine Bar — The Date Night Steal
Location: 522 King St W
For a spot that’s both chic and cozy, Cibo Wine Bar in Yorkville offers a deal that’s hard to pass up: half-priced pizzas every Tuesday. Picture it—golden, bubbly crusts made from homemade dough, topped with fresh ingredients, all served in an atmosphere that’s the perfect mix of romantic and laid-back. It’s the kind of place where a night out with your bestie turns into a memorable evening that makes you want to stay for just one more slice. Trust us, after tasting these heavenly pies at a fraction of the price, you’ll be making Tuesdays your official pizza night.
- Website: https://www.cibo.menu/
- Instagram: cibo_winebar
Blaze Pizza — The Swipe Right
Location: 10 Dundas Street East
Blaze Pizza is like that swipe-right moment on your dating app that actually leads to a real date. With its build-your-own concept and unlimited toppings at just over $15, it’s casual, fast, and remarkably satisfying. You can pile on artichokes, roasted red peppers, and just the right amount of mozzarella—no judgment, no drama. Your pizza’s ready in minutes, making it perfect for those days when you’re on the go but don’t want to sacrifice flavor. It’s reliable and as unpretentious as a walk down Yonge Street on a sunny afternoon.
- Website: www.blazepizza.com
- Instagram: blazepizza
King Slice — The Big Slice on the Block
Location: 1130 Queen Street West
If you’re a fan of pizza slices as big as your face, King Slice is the spot for you. Their massive New York-style slices start at $5, making it the ultimate grab-and-go option on Queen West. For those who want to go all in, their jumbo-sized whole pizzas are ideal for sharing—perfect for when you want to impress your friends with a single, towering slice. Whether you’re a purist who loves a simple cheese pizza or a thrill-seeker who craves something piled high with toppings, King Slice will leave you satisfied and wondering why you ever settled for less.
- Website: www.kingslice.ca
- Instagram: kingslicepizza
Petty Cash — The Trendy Night Out
Location: 487 Adelaide Street West
If you’re looking for the ultimate fusion of nightlife and comfort food, Petty Cash is where it’s at. Happy hour runs every day from 5-9 p.m., and you can score half-priced pizzas to go with your cocktails. It’s the kind of place where good food, good drinks, and great company come together effortlessly. The vibe? Fun and unpretentious, just like their pizza specials that keep you coming back for more. With a place this good, you’ll want to make it your new weekend ritual. Period.
- Website: pettycashtoronto.com
- Instagram: pettycashto
Pizzaiolo — The Reliable Chain
Location: Multiple Locations across Downtown Toronto
With several locations across the city, Pizzaiolo has mastered the art of consistency—because sometimes, you just want to know what you’re getting. From classic margheritas to creative combos, Pizzaiolo is like that reliable friend you can count on, wherever you are in the city. And in a place as bustling as Toronto, that kind of dependability is worth every penny.
- Website: pizzaiolo.ca
- Instagram: pizzaiologourmetpizza
Maker Pizza — The Big Statement
Location: 59 Cameron Street (Multiple locations)
Maker Pizza is unapologetically bold—like showing up at a party wearing a statement coat that you know will turn heads. Their “Dr. Pepperoni” ($25) is a mouthwatering masterpiece, generously topped with extra-large slices of pepperoni, bursting with flavor and oozing with just the right amount of cheese. And if you’re looking for a deal, they’ve got you covered with their $3.75 Slice Thursday special—available until 4 p.m. at multiple locations. This is not your quick lunch break fix; it’s the pizza you want when you’re ready to indulge and maybe even share a slice with someone who appreciates the finer things—like quality pepperoni.
- Website: www.makerpizza.com
- Instagram: makerpizza
Finding a pizza that balances taste and price in Downtown Toronto is no easy feat, but the hunt is half the fun. Just like the city itself, these seven pizzerias offer something for everyone—from the budget-conscious student to the foodie who believes that pizza should be a love language of its own. So, the next time you’re wandering through the city with a craving for something familiar yet extraordinary, take a chance on one of these spots. Who knows? You might just find your new favorite slice—and maybe even someone to share it with.
If you’re craving even more pizza recommendations or want to explore Toronto’s vibrant food scene, keep checking back on Hungry416.com. We’re your go-to source for the best eats, unbeatable deals, and insider tips on where to find the tastiest bites this city has to offer. Because life’s too short for bad food—and definitely too short for bad pizza.
References
https://www.destinationtoronto.com/leisure-blog/post/local-picks-best-pizza-toronto/
https://torontolife.com/food/toronto-best-cheap-pizza-slices-right-now/
https://www.yelp.ca/search?find_desc=Cheap+Pizza&find_loc=Toronto%2C+ON
