10+ Best Pie Shops in Toronto (Ontario)
Craving a slice of heaven? Toronto’s pie scene is bursting with flavor, offering everything from classic fruit pies to savory creations that’ll make your taste buds sing. Whether you’re a sweet tooth or a savory seeker, our guide to the 10+ best pie shops in Toronto will have you saying “pie love you” to every delicious bite.
keep up with the latest
1. Pies by Squires
Pies by Squires is a British-style pie shop on Ossington Avenue. They have a variety of savory pies, including steak and ale, chicken and mushroom, and lamb and rosemary. They also have a few sweet pies, like apple and blueberry. Their pies are made with fresh, local ingredients, and they have a cozy atmosphere that’s perfect for a casual meal.
- https://piesbysquires.com
- 202 Ossington Ave, Toronto
2. Pie Squared
This cheery spot offers handheld pies with a British twist. Whether you’re craving a savory steak and ale pie or a sweet apple crumble, they’ve got you covered. Their quick service and affordable prices make them a popular lunchtime spot.
- https://www.piesquared.com
- 21 St. Clair Ave West, Toronto
- +1 647-349-7432
- contactus@piesquared.com
3. Sharman’s Proper Pies
Sharman’s Proper Pies on the Danforth is a Toronto institution. They’ve been serving up delicious pies since 1975, and they’re still going strong. Their menu features a variety of classic pies, like steak and kidney, chicken pot pie, and shepherd’s pie.
- https://sharmansproper.ca
- 1972 Danforth Ave, Toronto
- +1 416-901-7437
- info@sharmansproper.ca
4. The Pie Commission
This Etobicoke gem is known for its gourmet pies, made with high-quality ingredients. Their menu features a variety of creative flavors, like butter chicken, steak and guinness, and wild mushroom. They also offer frozen pies for takeout, so you can enjoy them at home.
- https://piecommission.com
- 927 The Queensway, Etobicoke
- 416-848-7424
5. Wanda’s Pie in the Sky
Wanda’s Pie in the Sky is a Kensington Market staple. They’re known for their sweet and savory pies, made with fresh, local ingredients. Their menu features a variety of classic pies, like apple, cherry, and pecan, as well as more unique flavors, like chocolate peanut butter and blueberry lavender.
- http://wandaspieinthesky.com
- 287 Augusta Ave, Toronto
- 416-236-7585
Follow us for new eats & updates!
6. Rob’s Good Food
This East York spot is a local favorite. They’re known for their hearty, home-style pies, like chicken pot pie, shepherd’s pie, and tourtiere. Their pies are made with fresh ingredients, and they’re always served hot and fresh.
- https://www.robsgoodfood.com
- 813 O’Connor Dr, East York
- 416-447-3790
7. Sweetie Pie (Queen St.)
This Queen West bakery is known for its sweet and savory pies. Their menu features a variety of classic pies, like apple, cherry, and pecan, as well as more unique flavors, like chocolate peanut butter and blueberry lavender.
- https://www.mysweetiepie.ca
- 654 Queen St W, Toronto
- 416-613-9372
8. Brick Street Bakery
This Distillery District bakery is a popular spot for tourists and locals alike. They’re known for their fresh-baked bread, pastries, and pies. Their menu features a variety of savory pies, like chicken pot pie, steak and kidney, and shepherd’s pie.
- https://www.brickstreetbakery.com
- 27 Trinity St, Toronto
- 416-214-4949
9. Mabel’s Bakery & Specialty Foods
While primarily known for its gourmet sandwiches and fresh-baked bread, Mabel’s also offers a selection of seasonal pies that rotate throughout the year. Their fruit pies, like apple and peach, are made with locally sourced ingredients and have a flaky, buttery crust.
- http://mabelsbakery.ca
- 2755 Dundas St W, Toronto
- 416-519-4375
10. New Pie Co
This Dundas West bakery is a newcomer to the Toronto pie scene, but they’ve already made a big impression. Their menu features a variety of creative flavors, like butter chicken, steak and guinness, and wild mushroom.
- @newpieco
- 1561 Dundas St W, Toronto
11. Athens Pastries
While primarily known for its Greek pastries, Athens Pastries also offers a delicious selection of meat pies. Their spanakopita, a savory spinach and feta pie, is a must-try for vegetarians and meat-eaters alike.
- https://athenspastries.com
- 509 Danforth Ave, Toronto
- 416-463-5144
- info@athenspastries.com
References:
