10+ Best Pie Shops in Toronto (Ontario)

· · ·

Craving a slice of heaven? Toronto’s pie scene is bursting with flavor, offering everything from classic fruit pies to savory creations that’ll make your taste buds sing. Whether you’re a sweet tooth or a savory seeker, our guide to the 10+ best pie shops in Toronto will have you saying “pie love you” to every delicious bite.

1. Pies by Squires 

Best Pie Shops in Toronto
Photo by @piesbysquires / Instagram 

Pies by Squires is a British-style pie shop on Ossington Avenue. They have a variety of savory pies, including steak and ale, chicken and mushroom, and lamb and rosemary. They also have a few sweet pies, like apple and blueberry. Their pies are made with fresh, local ingredients, and they have a cozy atmosphere that’s perfect for a casual meal.

2. Pie Squared

Best Pie Shops in Toronto
Photo via @pie2squared / Instagram 

This cheery spot offers handheld pies with a British twist. Whether you’re craving a savory steak and ale pie or a sweet apple crumble, they’ve got you covered. Their quick service and affordable prices make them a popular lunchtime spot.

3. Sharman’s Proper Pies

Sharman’s Proper Pies on the Danforth is a Toronto institution. They’ve been serving up delicious pies since 1975, and they’re still going strong. Their menu features a variety of classic pies, like steak and kidney, chicken pot pie, and shepherd’s pie.

4. The Pie Commission

Best Pie Shops in Toronto
Photo via @thepiecommission / Instagram 

This Etobicoke gem is known for its gourmet pies, made with high-quality ingredients. Their menu features a variety of creative flavors, like butter chicken, steak and guinness, and wild mushroom. They also offer frozen pies for takeout, so you can enjoy them at home.

5. Wanda’s Pie in the Sky

Best Pie Shops in Toronto
Photo via @wandaspieinthesky / Instagram 

Wanda’s Pie in the Sky is a Kensington Market staple. They’re known for their sweet and savory pies, made with fresh, local ingredients. Their menu features a variety of classic pies, like apple, cherry, and pecan, as well as more unique flavors, like chocolate peanut butter and blueberry lavender.

6. Rob’s Good Food

Best Pie Shops in Toronto
Photo via @robsgoodfood / Instagram 

This East York spot is a local favorite. They’re known for their hearty, home-style pies, like chicken pot pie, shepherd’s pie, and tourtiere. Their pies are made with fresh ingredients, and they’re always served hot and fresh.

7. Sweetie Pie (Queen St.)

Photo via @mysweetiepie.ca / Instagram

This Queen West bakery is known for its sweet and savory pies. Their menu features a variety of classic pies, like apple, cherry, and pecan, as well as more unique flavors, like chocolate peanut butter and blueberry lavender.

8. Brick Street Bakery

Photo via @brickstreetbakery / Instagram 

This Distillery District bakery is a popular spot for tourists and locals alike. They’re known for their fresh-baked bread, pastries, and pies. Their menu features a variety of savory pies, like chicken pot pie, steak and kidney, and shepherd’s pie.

9. Mabel’s Bakery & Specialty Foods

Photo via @mabelsbakery / Instagram 

While primarily known for its gourmet sandwiches and fresh-baked bread, Mabel’s also offers a selection of seasonal pies that rotate throughout the year. Their fruit pies, like apple and peach, are made with locally sourced ingredients and have a flaky, buttery crust.

10. New Pie Co

Photo via @newpieco / Instagram 

This Dundas West bakery is a newcomer to the Toronto pie scene, but they’ve already made a big impression. Their menu features a variety of creative flavors, like butter chicken, steak and guinness, and wild mushroom.

11. Athens Pastries

Photo by @eatwithme.eg via @athenspastries / Instagram 

While primarily known for its Greek pastries, Athens Pastries also offers a delicious selection of meat pies. Their spanakopita, a savory spinach and feta pie, is a must-try for vegetarians and meat-eaters alike.

References:

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *