10+ Best Peameal Bacon Sandwich Spots in Toronto
Toronto is a city that knows how to do breakfast right—especially when it comes to the iconic peameal bacon sandwich. If you’ve never sunk your teeth into one, it’s time to change that. The crispy, salty goodness of thick-cut peameal bacon, tucked into a soft bun, has earned its place as a local legend. Whether you’re a lifelong lover or a curious newcomer, Toronto’s sandwich scene is packed with spots where this humble bacon creation shines. Here is a roundup of our top 10+. Get ready to explore the best places to indulge in this savory delight, where each bite brings a mouthful of nostalgia, flavor, and, yes, a whole lot of bacon.
Best Peameal Bacon Sandwich Spots in Toronto
The Patrician Grill
Step into a time capsule at The Patrician Grill, where the charm of old-school diners meets the sizzle of Toronto’s iconic peameal bacon. Located at King St., this spot has been flipping hearty breakfasts and pouring bottomless coffee since the 1960s. To some regulars, their peameal bacon sandwich isn’t just a meal—it’s a hug on a bun, with thick-cut bacon grilled to golden perfection and nestled in a fresh kaiser roll.
- Price: $-$$
- Location: 219 King St E, Toronto, ON M5A 1J9
- Website: www.patriciangrill.com
- Phone: (416) 366-4841
New Yorker Deli
The peameal bacon sandwich at New Yorker Deli in Toronto is a satisfying combination of tender, flavorful peameal bacon, melted cheddar, and scrambled eggs, served on your choice of bread. It’s a hearty meal that pairs perfectly with their signature home fries or crispy latkes.
- Price: $-$$
- Location: 1140 Bay St., Toronto, ON M5S 2B4
- Instagram: @newyorkerdeli_to
- Website: www.newyorkerdeli.meemup.com
- Phone: (416) 923-3354
Amazing Ted’s Diner
Standing strong since ‘54, Amazing Ted’s Diner is the kind of place where the coffee is strong, the vibes are retro, and the peameal bacon sandwiches steal the show. With sandwich options ranging from plain, to deluxe, to specials, you’ll be coming back for more. With vintage décor and a staff that feels like family, this east-end gem has a reputation for bringing serious flavor.
- Price: $-$$
- Location: 404 Old Kingston Rd, Scarborough, ON M1C 1B6
- Phone: (416) 282-2204
Bodega Henriette
The BBQ Peameal Sandwich at Bodega Henriette combines savory house-made peameal bacon, a fried egg, crispy onions, and fresh arugula, all brought together with a tangy mustard and rum BBQ sauce on a soft brioche bun. It’s a hearty option with bold flavors, served alongside crispy fingerling potatoes.
- Price: $-$$
- Location: 1801 Gerrard St E, Toronto, ON M4L 2B4
- Instagram: @bodegahenriette
- Website: www.bodegahenriette.com
- Phone: (416) 546-6261
Leslieville Pumps
Leslieville Pumps combines the best of comfort food and cozy atmosphere, making it a local favorite for peameal bacon sandwiches. This spot serves up the classic version with perfectly cooked, thick-cut peameal bacon on a soft bun, and a generous helping of condiments to complement the smoky, savory flavor. Regulars rave about the “classic diner feel” and the sandwich’s consistently delicious quality. It’s a sandwich that’s as unpretentious as the setting but packs a gourmet-level punch.
- Price: $-$$
- Location: 913 Queen St E, Toronto, ON M4M 1J4
- Instagram: @the_pumps
- Website: www.leslievillepumps.com
- Phone: (416) 465-1313
Avenue Open Kitchen
Stashed on Camden Street, Avenue Open Kitchen serves a no-frills peameal bacon sandwich that’s all about the flavor. The sandwich’s “crispy edges and tender center” strike the perfect balance of salty and savory. With its diner-style seating and friendly staff, this spot feels like Toronto’s best-kept breakfast secret.
- Price: $-$$
- Location: 7 Camden St, Toronto, ON M5V 2K6
- Phone: (416) 504-7131
The Merseyside
A cozy corner café on Dundas West, The Merseyside serves a peameal bacon sandwich that’s simple but oh-so-satisfying. Their sandwich is “perfect for a lazy brunch,” with its tender bacon, toasted bun, and a smear of tangy sauce. This unassuming spot is a favorite for locals who crave quality without the fuss.
- Price: $
- Location: 2413 Dundas St W, Toronto, ON M6P 1X3
- Instagram: @merseysideto
- Phone: (647) 679-3113
Insomnia
Insomnia on Bloor Street brings a touch of sophistication to the humble peameal bacon sandwich. Known for its late-night eats and lively ambiance, this spot has been praised for its “crispy, flavorful bacon paired with fluffy buns.” Whether you’re there for brunch or a midnight snack, Insomnia’s version of the classic sandwich is worth the hype.
- Price: $-$$$
- Location: 563 Bloor St W, Toronto, ON M5S 1Y6
- Instagram: @insomniatoronto
- Phone: (416) 588-3907
When the Pig Came Home
With a name like that, you know the bacon game is serious. Located in the Junction, When the Pig Came Home is a deli that’s built a cult following for its peameal bacon sandwich. The “generous portions” and “smoky, caramelized flavor” make every bite unforgettable. Add their house-made sauces, and you’ve got a sandwich that’s nothing short of legendary.
- Price: $-$$
- Location: 384 Keele St, Toronto, ON M6P 2K8
- Instagram: @when_the_pig_came_home
- Phone: (647) 345-9001
Paddington’s Pump
If St. Lawrence Market is Toronto’s culinary epicenter, then Paddington’s Pump is its bacon-filled heart. Famous for its peameal bacon sandwich, this diner delivers juicy, perfectly cooked slices stacked on a soft bun with mustard and a side of nostalgia. It’s been described as “the quintessential Toronto food experience” that’s worth every bite.
- Price: $-$$
- Location: 91 Front St E, Toronto, ON M5E 1C3
- Instagram: @paddingtonspumpto
- Phone: (416) 368-6955
Carousel Bakery
Did we save the best for last? You decide, but no list of peameal bacon sandwiches is complete without Carousel Bakery, the OG of St. Lawrence Market. Their “World Famous Peameal Bacon Sandwich” lives up to its name, drawing praise for its simplicity and flavor-packed punch. Thick slices of peameal bacon on a pillow-like bun make this sandwich a must-try for locals and tourists alike.
- Price: $
- Location: 93 Front St E, Toronto, ON M5E 1M6
- Phone: (416) 363-4247
Try out the best peameal bacon sandwich spots in Toronto and let us know which was your favorite down in the comments. If you wish to read more content like this, sign up to our newsletter or follow us on social media.
More…
