St. Catharines Restaurant Tops Air Canada’s Best New Restaurants 2026 List
Ontario is on top of Air Canada’s latest national restaurant ranking, but the biggest result didn’t come from Toronto. Restaurant Capelin in St. Catharines took first place in Air Canada’s Best New Restaurants 2026 list, released on November 16.

Four Ontario restaurants landed in the Top 10. Collingwood’s LORE, St. Catharines’ Les Incompetents and Toronto’s Bar Eugenie joined Capelin. That gives St. Catharines two entries, while Toronto has one in the final ranking.
The list arrives during the program’s 25th year. It covers newer openings across the country, from small chef-run counters to restaurants serving casual plates. This year’s results also come with extra awards for a dish, restaurant design and overall concept.
Four Ontario restaurants made the Top 10
No. 1: Restaurant Capelin, St. Catharines. Chef Alex Seaborn and Kat Seaborn opened Capelin in June 2025. Its seafood-focused tasting menu changes with the seasons, using fish and produce sourced from Ontario and elsewhere in Canada. Air Canada also gave its Dashi Custard the 2026 Best Dish award.
For anyone considering a Niagara dinner trip, Capelin is at 31 James Street in downtown St. Catharines. The restaurant’s reservation page currently lists one 6:30 p.m. seating on Thursday, Friday and Saturday evenings. Bookings are required, and the menu changes based on what is available.
No. 8: LORE, Collingwood. LORE makes modern Canadian tasting menus built around seasonal ingredients. The multi-course format puts its own spin on foods diners may already know, rather than relying on a traditional à la carte setup.
No. 9: Les Incompetents, St. Catharines. This French-leaning restaurant and cocktail bar gives the city another spot on the list. Its menu puts seafood and raw-bar dishes beside bistro-style small plates. With Capelin at No. 1, St. Catharines is the only Ontario city with two restaurants in the Top 10.
No. 10: Bar Eugenie, Toronto. Harbord Village’s entry serves wood-fired dishes and a changing selection of plates to share. Canadian ingredients and Filipino influences appear across the menu. The restaurant also took home Air Canada’s Best Design award for 2026. It is at 89 Harbord Street, and its official website lists current service information.
Air Canada’s full 2026 Top 10 ranking
The national list includes restaurants in five provinces, with Ontario claiming four of the ten positions:
- Restaurant Capelin — St. Catharines, Ontario
- Sushi Jun — Calgary, Alberta
- Snack Haüs — Winnipeg, Manitoba
- 3 Pierres 1 Feu — Montréal, Québec
- Angela Pastificio — Vancouver, British Columbia
- Coquette — Sainte-Anne-de-Beaupré, Québec
- Touk — Vancouver, British Columbia
- LORE — Collingwood, Ontario
- Les Incompetents — St. Catharines, Ontario
- Bar Eugenie — Toronto, Ontario
How Air Canada selected the winners
Air Canada’s ranking does not come from public voting. A group of culinary tastemakers first nominated 30 finalists. Then an anonymous culinary expert visited the restaurants as a regular guest, assessing food, service, design, concept and the overall meal.
Under the program’s 2026 eligibility window, restaurants had to open between May 1, 2025, and April 30, 2026. This keeps the focus on recent arrivals rather than long-running neighbourhood favourites. It also means a restaurant can be well known locally by the time the final list comes out.
Those judging criteria help explain the range of winners. A seafood tasting menu, a counter devoted to Japanese omakase and a small kitchen serving handheld food can all appear in one ranking.
New awards recognize dishes, design and concept
The Top 10 is not the only recognition this year. Capelin’s Dashi Custard won Best Dish, while Bar Eugenie earned Best Design. Vancouver’s Angela Pastificio, a 20-seat restaurant serving handmade fresh pasta and a seasonal tasting menu, received Best Concept.
The three awards point to specific parts of a restaurant’s work. They do not change the numbered ranking, which still puts Capelin first and Bar Eugenie tenth.
Jen Agg and Mark McEwan join the new Icons group
For its 25th anniversary, Air Canada also created a Best New Restaurants Icons group. Toronto chefs Jen Agg and Mark McEwan were named in the first class.
They join Janice Tiefenbach and Emma Cardarelli of Montréal, Daniel Costa of Edmonton and Joël Watanabe of Vancouver. The honour focuses on people whose restaurants and careers helped shape Canada’s dining scene over time, separate from the 2026 newcomers.
The program also plans a DINR dining series in 2027 for Aeroplan members, featuring one-night chef collaborations. The announcement does not include dates or ticket details, so anyone interested will need to watch for a separate release.
Where to check menus and reservations
For Toronto diners, Bar Eugenie is the local name on the list. Capelin is the top-ranked option for anyone planning a meal in Niagara, but its shared seating makes advance reservations important. Air Canada’s full 2026 Top 10 has the complete rankings and restaurant profiles.
You Might Also Like…