Best Dessert Spots in Niagara-on-The-Lake

Nestled in the picturesque town of Niagara-on-the-Lake, Ontario, the dessert scene offers a delightful array of sweet treats that cater to every palate. These 15+ dessert spots in Niagara are guaranteed to provide an assortment of baked goods and sweet treats for an indulgent experience. Whether you’re looking for gelato, chocolate, or freshly baked pies, Niagara-on-the-Lake is a sweet destination that promises to satisfy every dessert lover’s dreams.
1. Gelato di carlotta
Gelato di Carlotta stands out as a must-visit destination for gelato enthusiasts. This bar-café offers a delightful array of gelato and sorbetto, complemented by specialty coffees like cappuccinos and espressos. Indulge in unique gelato creations, including cakes, biscotto sandwiches, mini-cones, and gelato on a stick. The business prides themselves in using an organic base imported from Italy, combined with organic cream, milk, grape sugar, and off-white raw cane sugar. Their commitment to quality means their gelato is over 80% organic, with sourced exquisite ingredients from around the world.
- Where: 59 Queen St., Niagara-On-The-Lake
- When: 8am-11pm (7 days a week)
- Price range: $$
- Spot Type: Bar-café
- What they Offer: Gelato, sorbetto, coffee, biscotto, cakes
- Dietary Options: Gluten-Free
- Website: www.gelatodicarlotta.com/
2. The Pie plate
Founded as a humble family bakery in 2003, The Pie Plate has grown into a vibrant local hotspot. Their homemade pies, bread and baked goods initially sparked local interest, and the business began partnering with nearby fruit farmers, cheese artisans, and meat suppliers to craft unique sandwiches on our signature baguettes, gourmet thin-crust pizzas, and an ever-changing selection of small plates. Their menu now also features distinctive cocktails that pair perfectly with local craft beers and wines.
- Where: 1607 Four Mile Creek Road, Niagara-On-The-Lake
- When: 8am-6pm (7 days a week)
- Price range: $$
- Spot Type: Eat-in
- What they Offer: Pies, tarts, baked goods, sandwiches, artisanal pizza, coffee
- Dietary Options: Gluten-Free
- Website: www.thepieplate.com/
3. cowS Niagara-on-the-lake

COWS started crafting ice cream in 1983 with a cherished family recipe from Cavendish, Prince Edward Island. They use the same time-honored ingredients for its 36+ flavors made in Charlottetown. Each batch of ice cream is lovingly handmade with premium ingredients, including 16% butterfat, fresh cream, and real eggs, and is served in a handmade waffle cone. Central to COWS Ice Cream’s rich taste is the use of local Prince Edward Island milk, which enhances the flavor and quality of every delightful bite.
- Where: 59 Queen St., Niagara-On-The-Lake
- When: 10AM- 9PM (7 days a week)
- Price range: $
- Spot Type: Ice creamery
- What they Offer: Gelato, sorbetto, coffee, biscotto, cakes
- Dietary Options: Gluten-Free
- Website: https://cows.ca/
4. budapest bakeshop
Experience this age-old traditional Hungarian dessert, the Chimney Cake, at the Budapest Bakeshop. Each chimney cake at the bakery is meticulously prepared, hand-rolled, and baked from scratch daily. You can even step into the bakeshop and witness the entire baking process up close in this immersive experience — from mixing and rolling to rising, baking, and adding delectable toppings and fillings. Their sweet yeast dough is freshly made and prepared several times a day. Choose between their sweet, savory or sausage chimneys, or chimney sandwiches. Then, choose your favorite topping, find the end, and watch as your chimney cake unfurls into a delicious treat!
- Where: 118 Queen Street, Niagara on the Lake
- When: 9 a.m. to 6:30 p.m. (7 days a week)
- Price range: $
- Spot Type: Bakery
- What they Offer: Chimney cakes, chimney sandwiches
- Dietary Options: N/A
- Website: www.budapestbakeshop.com/
5. Nina’s Gelateria and Pastry shop

Experience this gelateria’s all-natural, European-inspired pastries and authentic Italian gelato. Crafted from the finest ingredients and free from preservatives and artificial flavors, their treats are made fresh daily. At Nina’s, you can enjoy artisanal pastries, gourmet pizzas, and delicious panini sandwiches. They also offer a selection of expertly crafted espresso drinks, including cappuccinos and lattes, along with refreshing cold beverages. Experience the rich flavors and culinary traditions of Switzerland’s German, French, and Italian regions all in one place.
- Where: 37 Queen Street, Niagara-on-the-Lake
- When: 11am to 8pm (7 days a week)
- Price range: $$
- Spot Type: Bakery, ice creamery
- What they Offer: Gelato, artisanal pastries, pizzas, panini sandwiches, coffee beverages
- Dietary Options: Sugar free, keto- friendly
- Website: www.ninagelateria.com/
6. Niagara home bakery

In the heart of Niagara, Niagara Home Bakery is a dessert spots in Niagara for dessert enthusiasts and bakery lovers alike. This charming bakery is renowned for its warm, inviting atmosphere and a delightful array of freshly baked goods. From pies and tarts to delectable pastries and cookies, each treat is crafted with care and high-quality ingredients. Niagara Home Bakery offers a taste of homemade goodness that embodies the heart and soul of Niagara’s local baking scene.
- Where: 66 Queen St, Niagara-on-the-Lake
- When: 8:30am to 5pm (7 days a week)
- Price range: $
- Spot Type: Bakery
- What they Offer: Pies, tarts, pastries, cookies
- Dietary Options: Gluten free
7. Fritters on the lake
Discover this family-owned bakery, based in Niagara-on-the-Lake. Fritters On The Lake delights in crafting irresistible apple fritters that are as delicious as they are fresh. Thanks to their perfected family recipe that has captured widespread attention, these delicious apple fritters are perfect to eat while strolling in the city, or along the Lake. Their menu features classic apple fritters adorned with your choice of maple, caramel, or chocolate syrup, as well as a signature lake special topped with vanilla ice cream.
- Where: 217 King St., Niagara on the Lake
- When: 10am- 5pm (Wed- Sun)
- Price range: $
- Spot Type: Treat stop, takeout
- What they Offer: Apple fritters
- Dietary Options: N/A
8. Paris Crêpes Café

Discover the allure of an authentic French bistro experience. At Paris Crepes Cafe is dessert spots in Niagara, savor the charm of Paris with their delightful brunch, where you can enjoy both savory gluten-free crepes and decadently sweet options. As evening descends, embrace the ambiance of a classic Montmartre bistro with a dinner that transports you to the streets of Paris. Their menu also includes other classic French dishes such as ratatouille, escargots, moules and beef bourguignon.
- Where: 4613 Queen Street, Niagara Falls
- When:
- Price range: $$
- Spot Type: Brunch, Bistro
- What they Offer: Crepes, Classic French dishes
- Dietary Options: Gluten-Free
- Website: www.pariscrepescafe.com/
9. Rocky Mountain Chocolate Factory
Established in Whistler, BC, Rocky Mtn Chocolate Canada has grown into a beloved national brand. Driven by their passion for chocolate, the business is committed to excellence, they craft their confections in small, hand-made batches. Rocky Mountain is dessert spots in Niagara renowned for their exceptional boxed chocolates and classic caramel apples. At their stores, you can witness the artistry of hand-made fudge and apples dipped in rich caramel.
- Where: 70 Queen St, Niagara-on-the-Lake
- When: 10am- 8pm (7 days a week)
- Price range: $$- $$$
- Spot Type: Confectionary
- What they Offer: Boxed chocolate, chocolate bark, caramel apples, fudge
- Dietary Options: N/A
- Website: rockychoc.com/
10. Willow Cakes and Pastries
Entering Willow Cakes and Pastries is like stepping into a charming European patisserie. A blend of a local bakery and a sophisticated boutique, customers can admire an array of breads, chocolates, cakes, and tarts. Whether you’re seeking a stunning wedding cake, skillfully decorated cupcakes, cookies, cakepops, or a quick coffee and snack, Willow Cakes and Pastries is a delicious Niagara-on-the-Lake destination, aiming to wow customers with the perfect blend of taste and elegance.
- Where: 242 Mary St., Niagara-on-the-Lake
- When: 8 am – 6 pm (7 days a week)
- Price range: $$- $$$
- Spot Type: Bakery, cakeshop
- What they Offer: cakes, breads, tarts, cakepops, coffee
- Dietary Options: Gluten free
- Website: www.willowcakes.ca/
11. Beavertails
The beloved dessert and snack destination offers an impressive array of treats and snacks, attracting both tourists and locals. During the busy tourist season, lines can be long, but the dedicated staff ensures that each guest receives personalized and attentive service. Indulge in the iconic Canadian fried pastries topped with decadent delights, alongside savory snacks such as poutine, crispy fries, and hot dogs.
- Where: 242 Mary St., Niagara-on-the-Lake
- When: 12pm to 9pm (7 days a week)
- Price range: $
- Spot Type: Food stand
- What they Offer: Iconic “Beavertails” treat
- Dietary Options: N/A
- Website: beavertails.com/
12. Avondale Dairy Bar
Crafted in their charming dairy bar nestled in the countryside of Niagara-on-the-Lake, Avondale Dairy Bar is a beloved ice cream destination. Indulge in a diverse selection of banana splits, ice cream sundaes, classic sodas, floats, and milkshakes, all crafted with a touch of nostalgia. Their ice cream scoops are a crowd-pleaser, served on your choice of cone for the ultimate treat. Avondale’s ice cream is crafted daily on-site using time-honored techniques, delivering unparalleled quality and taste, including a rich 15% dairy butterfat base to create their exceptional flavors.
- Where: 461 Stewart Rd, Niagara-on-the-Lake
- When: 12pm to 9pm (7 days a week)
- Price range: $
- Spot Type: Ice creamery, Take-out
- What they Offer: Banada splits, ice cream sundaes, cones, sodas, floats, milkshakes
- Dietary Options: N/A
- Website: avondaledairybar.com/
13. SOKO Bakery and Cafe
Soko is a charming Korean-inspired bakery cafe where every detail is crafted with care. This dessert spots in Niagara offers a delightful array of fresh roll cakes, sandwiches, and pastries, baked daily with premium ingredients and a touch of sweetness. Whether you’re looking for gluten-free, dairy-free, or plant-based options, they’ve got you covered with custom requests. Brighten your day with delicious meals, treats, and expertly brewed espresso beverages.
- Where: 358 Mary St, Niagara-on-the-Lake
- When: 8:30am- 4pm (7 days a week)
- Price range: $-$$
- Spot Type: Korean bakery-cafe
- What they Offer: Roll cakes, sandwiches, pastries, espresso, cold beverages
- Dietary Options: Gluten-free, dairy-free, plant-based options
- Website: sokobakerycafe.square.site/
14. Doughvine Bakehouse
Doughvine Bakehouse is a dessert spots in Niagara family-owned bakery, a proud independent gem that specializes in crafting artisan doughnuts and boulangerie-style delights made fresh in-house every day. Their mission is to honor the rich heritage of Niagara by using traditional baking methods passed down through the centuries. Their menu includes sweet doughnuts, fritters and bagels. Not to mention, specialty drinks such as coffees, teas, and cold drinks.
- Where: 183 Victoria Street, Niagara-on-the-Lake
- When: 10am- 7pm (Friday to Monday)
- Price range: $
- Spot Type: Bakery
- What they Offer: Doughnuts, fritters, bagels, specialty drinks, coffee, tea
- Dietary Options: Gluten-free
- Website: https://doughvine.ca/home
15. The Sweet Oven Niagara

The Sweet Oven takes pride in crafting exquisite Canadian treats, including their renowned homemade butter tarts. Baked fresh each day, their bakery focuses on perfecting butter tarts, cheesecakes, and cookies. Their butter tarts feature over 20 unique flavors, including Pecan, Raisin, Raspberry, and Oreo. Experience their perfect bite-sized mini cheesecakes, featuring flavors such as Chocolate, Lemon, or Black Cherry. Their cookie lineup also includes beloved classics like chocolate chunk and oatmeal raisin.
- Where: 3507 Portage Rd, Niagara Falls
- When: 9am- 4pm (7 days a week)
- Price range: $-$$
- Spot Type: Bakery
- What they Offer: Butter tarts, cheesecakes, cookies
- Dietary Options: N/A
- Website: https://sweetovenniagara.com/
16. Cake Cafe
Cake Cafe offers a delightful range of treats, from custom cakes whimsical floral cupcake bouquets. Each creation is made with love and imagination. Indulge in their heavenly butter tarts, cookies, and cheesecakes that promise to delight your taste buds. Experience the decadent Cake Cafe, where every treat is a celebration of passion, and dedication.
- Where: 1615 Niagara Stone Road – Unit 3. Niagara-on-the-Lake
- When: 10am- 6pm (7 days a week)
- Price range: $$-$$$
- Spot Type: Bakery, cake shop
- What they Offer: Custom cakes, butter tarts, cookies, cheesecakes
- Dietary Options: N/A
- Website: https://www.cakecafe.ca/
References: