Best Butter Tarts in Toronto | Top Spots for Canadian Classics
Toronto’s butter tart scene is a slice of heaven for anyone with a sweet tooth! These iconic Canadian treats, with their flaky crusts and gooey, caramel-like centers, have been winning hearts for generations. From classic to inventive twists, the city’s bakeries have butter tarts to satisfy every craving. Here’s where you’ll find some of the very best butter tarts in Toronto.
Where to Find the Best Butter Tarts in Toronto
1. Gerrard Street Bakery
Gerrard Street Bakery is a must-visit for butter tart lovers looking for a bit of adventure. They offer flavours that range from classic to creative, each encased in a perfectly flaky crust. Their balance of sweet and salty in a gooey filling has made them a Toronto favourite. Stop by and discover a new twist on this traditional treat.
- 635 Gerrard Street Toronto
- 416-465-4567
- www.gerrardstreetbakery.com/
2. Circles & Squares
Renowned for their buttery pastries, Circles & Squares brings butter tarts to a new level. Each tart has a flaky crust filled with a rich, gooey center that makes for an indulgent bite. If you’re looking for a classic butter tart done right, this bakery is a must-visit.
- Davisville 1909 Yonge Street, Toronto
- 416-534-1511
- www.circlesandsquares.ca/
3. Ba Noi
Hidden away on Bloor Street, Ba Noi is a small bakery with big flavours. Their butter tarts have a luscious, caramel-like filling wrapped in a perfectly crisp crust. This spot is a true gem for dessert lovers looking to uncover a delightful surprise in every bite.
- 806 Bloor St. West
- ba-noi.myshopify.com/
4. Larry’s Folly
In Parkdale, Larry’s Folly is a cozy spot for coffee and a stellar butter tart. Free from nuts and raisins, their buttery, golden tarts keep it simple and delicious. Pick up a dozen for a true taste of nutty, caramel-like goodness without any extras—just pure butter tart bliss.
- 1462 Queen St W, Toronto
- +1 416-532-9898
- www.instagram.com/larrys_world
5. The Sweet Oven Toronto
The Sweet Oven is all about classic Canadian comfort. Their butter tarts are flaky, rich, and gooey—the ideal indulgence for any season. This October, you can also try their Pumpkin Spice butter tart, adding a hint of autumn warmth to an already delicious treat.
- 1911 Queen St E, Toronto
- +1 416-519-9559
- thesweetoven.com/
6. The Pie Commission
The Pie Commission is celebrated for its buttery, flaky crusts and locally sourced ingredients. Their butter tarts have a creamy, sweet filling that’s satisfying without being too rich. Perfect for those looking for a quality dessert, their tarts make any occasion a little sweeter.
- 1578 Bayview Ave Toronto
- (416) 322-0368
- piecommission.com/?srsltid=AfmBOoq7QRETFfqT71d34sTARytNyJgtZL8n6ACrx_3U1BJXtRcG8rQi
7. The Maids’ Cottage
Though, part of GTA, The Maids’ Cottage has been delighting Toronto for decades and is known for its legendary butter tarts. With a crust that’s flaky and a filling that’s gooey and rich, each tart is crafted with care. It’s a place that’s earned its reputation as a butter tart icon in the city.
- 223 Main Street S. Newmarket
- (905) 954-0202
- themaidscottage.com/
8. Phipps Bakery Cafe
Phipps Bakery Cafe delivers butter tarts that are both buttery and gooey. Each bite has a balance of sweetness with a hint of tang, making it a delicious experience. Every tart is made in-house with dedication to tradition, making them a standout in Toronto’s butter tart scene.
- 420 Eglinton Ave W Toronto
- (416) 481-9111
- www.phippsbakerycafe.ca
9. Dough Bakeshop
Dough Bakeshop’s butter tarts are as classic as they come, with a flaky crust and a rich filling. Walk in, and you’ll instantly smell the sweet aroma of freshly baked treats. It’s a welcoming spot that feels like home with every bite.
- 173 Danforth Ave, Toronto
- +1 416-465-2253
- www.doughbakeshop.ca/
10. Sweet Bliss Baking Company
In Leslieville, Sweet Bliss has become a go-to for pastry fans. Their butter tarts are made with love, from the flaky crust to the buttery filling. With its cozy vibe and nostalgic treats, Sweet Bliss is a delightful stop for anyone craving an authentic butter tart experience.
- Leslieville 1304 Queen St E Toronto
- (416) 916-7895
- www.sweetblissleslieville.com/#eat-together
References:
