New Italian Restaurants Toronto: Must-Try Spots for 2025
Toronto’s Italian dining scene continues to grow, and 2025 has introduced several standout additions across the city. These new Italian restaurants Toronto diners are discovering offer everything from handmade pasta and regional specialties to modern takes on classic dishes.
If you’re planning a date night, a casual dinner, or a meal centred around great wine and Italian comfort food, these new Italian restaurants Toronto food lovers should know about are worth adding to your list.
Where to Eat: Toronto’s Best New Italian Restaurants (2025 Guide)
Florin Trattoria (Financial District)
Address: 80 Richmond St W, Toronto
Florin Trattoria brings Florence into downtown Toronto. The space mixes old-world texture with a sharp, modern tone. The menu is full of Tuscan details—olive oil, rosemary, thick steaks, and handmade pasta that stays simple but satisfying. The bistecca alla Fiorentina is a standout, and the wine list leans Italian but approachable.
Pro tip: Visit on a weeknight for a better chance at getting a table without a reservation. Ask your server about the kitchen’s standout dishes that evening for recommendations beyond the regular menu favourites.
Zia’s Place (Little Portugal)
Address: 1543 Dundas St W, Toronto
Zia’s Place feels like someone turned their nonna’s kitchen into a modern restaurant. From the Pasta Forever team, this Dundas West spot celebrates Southern Italian food—handmade pasta, natural wine, and small plates meant to share. The menu changes often but always stays close to homey, vegetable-forward flavours.
Pro Tip: Reserve ahead if you’re visiting on a weekend, as tables fill quickly. If reservations aren’t available, try the bar or front window seats, which are typically reserved for walk-ins.
Occhiolino (Harbord Village)
Address: 499 Bathurst St, Toronto
Chef Luke Donato’s Occhiolino is small, confident, and laser-focused on pasta. The name translates to “wink,” and that quiet sense of humour shows in the menu—freshly made noodles, rotating sauces, and plating that feels effortless. Every dish, from silky tagliolini to stuffed agnolotti, carries that same precision.
Pro Tip: Stop by the retail area before you leave to pick up fresh pasta to enjoy at home. Since the pasta is made on-site, it’s an easy way to bring a taste of your meal with you.
Radici Project (Little Italy)
Address: 588 College St, Toronto
Radici Project takes an experimental turn by blending Italian and Japanese techniques in a calm, tasting-menu format. Expect scallop crudo with citrus or miso-seasoned pasta with local herbs. It’s refined but not stiff, with a rhythm that makes each course feel intentional.
Pro Tip: Don’t fill up on the house-made bread early in the meal. The larger courses arrive later and are meant to be enjoyed as the experience unfolds.
Bisteccheria Sammarco (St. Lawrence / Front St)
Address: 4 Front St E, Toronto
From the team behind Osteria Giulia and Giulietta, Bisteccheria Sammarco brings the Italian steakhouse concept to life. It’s all about premium cuts, handmade pasta, and calm service. The 100-egg fettuccine and house-aged beef are early favourites for good reason.
Pro Tip: Come with an open mind and skip expectations of a traditional steakhouse menu. The restaurant focuses on a more refined Italian-inspired approach rather than familiar steakhouse classics.
Cento40 Trattoria
Address: 140 Woodbridge Ave, Woodbridge
Cento40 Trattoria keeps things simple and satisfying. The Roman-style menu features cacio e pepe, carbonara, and supplìdone the right way—with quality cheese, real guanciale, and balance over flash.
Pro Tip: Save room for dessert before finishing your meal. The house tiramisu is a popular choice and a fitting way to end an Italian dining experience.
Cafe Oro Di Napoli (Leslieville)
Address: 75 Jarvis St, Toronto
Cafe Oro Di Napoli is a small Leslieville pasta bar built for regulars. The counter setup keeps it social, while the kitchen focuses on handmade pasta with short, seasonal menus. The plates are simple, but the care is clear—from the noodles to the wine list.
Pro Tip: Visit in the afternoon for a lively café-style experience with espresso and lighter bites. In the evening, settle in with pasta and wine to enjoy a slower, more relaxed meal.
Whether you’re craving classic pasta or modern Italian twists, these new Italian restaurants Toronto offer fresh flavors and memorable dining experiences across the city in 2025.
FAQs:
They range from relaxed pasta-focused spots to more elevated, wine-driven dining experiences. Most strike a balance between comfort and craft.
Reservations are often recommended, especially for weekend dinners or popular new openings. Some spots may still accommodate walk-ins during off-peak hours.
Menus commonly feature handmade pasta, regional Italian classics, and updated interpretations of traditional dishes. You’ll also find options like steak, seafood, and curated wine pairings at select locations.
You Might Also Like…
